B.C. carbon tax rolls out on Canada Day

by julianw | June 30, 2008 at 06:08 pm | 814 views | 6 comments

Gas prices will rise by 2.5 cents/litre when British Columbia's carbon tax -- the first of its kind in North America -- comes into effect on Tuesday, and the political controversy surrounding the tax will probably flare up, too.

On Canada Day, British Columbians will likely be paying the highest gas prices in the country, thanks to a new provincial carbon tax that adds almost 2.5 cents to a litre of fuel and has turned service stations into the province's latest political battle ground.

Motorists are doing more than filling up at their local gas stations. They're fuming about gas politics.

Premier Gordon Campbell admits his government has a selling job to do on its new green tax, the first escalating consumer tax on carbon in Canada.

"The government should look at themselves first before they look at tackling little guys like me," said Trish O'Brien as she filled up her fuel efficient Suzuki Aerio. "I do what I can. I recycle everything that's not nailed down. I drive a small car and take the bus when I can, and I walk."

The carbon tax has been attacked by a remarkably wide range of groups, including motorists, fiscal-conservatives, left-leaning politicians, rural B.C. residents, and people I don't know how to categorize. A fair analysis comes from someone who supports the carbon tax in theory but argues that its politically unfeasible:
Seriously, this much-misunderstood carbon tax is being blown into a major issue for all the wrong reasons. In dollar terms, it's actually a pretty innocuous thing. What it adds up to is that every time you fill up the tank it's going to cost you the amount of a cup of coffee extra -- and most of the cash will be recycled back to most of us through provincial income tax cuts. This is a major controversy?

No. Actually, the real problem with the carbon tax isn't the price tag.

It's flaw is that it's a great academic theory, potentially a powerful tool to change our gas-guzzling ways. But in the real world of politics it's going to be almost impossible for any politician to implement in a serious way at the gas pump.

While opinion remains divided on the tax itself,  one of its provisions -- the "Climate Action Dividend," a $100 cheque given to all B.C. residents -- has been almost universally criticized. (I actually challenge you to find a sound defense of the dividend). NowPublic contributor Barry Artiste weighed in on Friday:
I am sure most of you in British Columbia got your $100.00 Environmental Cheque in the mail this week?

Now our illustrious Premier sans Disco Dance shoes, tries a new mode of style to dazzle us with brilliance, but baffle us with BullPOO!!  With Charts, Calculators, Spreadsheets, lots of distracting Hand waving, his New style is more akin to a Doug Henning Magic Show, with a touch of Circ de Soliel thrown in.

As we watch the show spellbound, Government minions are in the audience silently picking our pockets, after all you didn't think that $100.00 the Premier gave you was Free Money, Heavens NO, that was your Tax Dollars returning to sender.  Of course $100.00 today in the bank will net an interest rate of 0.03 cents per annum, but in Government legalise, when the Government gives you $100.00 of your own Money, they stand to reap tenfold in interest they will get back from you in carbon taxes for doing so.  Certainly doesn't seem a fair rate of interest for you, but then your Government never tells you the whole PACKAGE!  So sit back, shut up and watch the Show!
Ridiculously, a polygamist in Bountiful, B.C. may receive $10, 000 in cheques. Perhaps most hilariously, someone I know used his green cheque to buy a fancy leather wallet. Overall though, I'm impressed that Gordon Campbell has managed to stick to his guns as left and right-wing critics join forces to attack the carbon tax. Will the Premier survive a summer of high gas prices and growing opposition?

Add a comment Comments (6)

rpshen

I had no idea that we already had so many other forms of taxes on fuel in BC. This carbon tax doesn't seem like a bad idea initially at 2.5cents/litre but it's projected to increase to 7+ cents/litre. Isn't that a little too much?

Rob Peters
good stuff:

Great coverage. I'm going to put mine towards my new bike, Old Blue.

Jarrett Martineau
good stuff:

I just got my $100 'Climate Action Dividend' cheque from Gordon Campbell. I'm not exactly sure what I did to deserve it, but I feel strangely obligated to spend it on something 'green'. Am I missing something?

Paschen
good stuff:

julianw, I like this story. It's good stuff. I like the story, good subject. Personally I am in favour of the Tax and would even add an environmental clean up tax and a tax that would be invested in changing from fussil fuel to renuable energy sources!

Zlender

Is this just a new name for a tax so your government can get more money or do thay have plans what to do with it for the environment.

julianw

Zlender, no the tax serves an environmental purpose: it discourages people from burning fossil fuels by putting a price on carbon and it recycles the government's tax-generated surplus through income tax cuts.

Add a comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.

June 30, 2008 at 06:08 pm by julianw, 814 views, 6 comments

closeSign in to NowPublic

is reporting from